Your next senior finance hire is a business investment. Are you treating it like one?

In our previous article, To develop, retain or recruit? Closing the finance capability gap, we looked at how businesses should, in the first instance, look to identify, develop and retain required finance capability from within.

Sometimes, however, the potential capability does not exist internally or cannot be developed within the required timeframe. The challenge is deciding when an external appointment is necessary, particularly when high-impact finance talent can be difficult and expensive to secure.

External recruitment may be your only realistic option when:

• A strategic shift creates a lasting skills gap
• A critical deadline leaves no time to develop the expertise from within
• A key departure exposes a gap with no credible successor
• The business needs a genuinely different perspective

In each case, three questions point to the right answer:

1. Is the capability essential? If not, the answer may be role redesign, automation, external advice or redistributing responsibilities rather than another appointment.
2. Can it be built in time? If so, develop internally. If not, consider the external market.
3. Will the need last? If it is enduring, recruit permanently. If it is time-limited, consider interim or specialist support.

In an uncertain economic climate, where businesses are making fewer appointments, each finance hire carries greater weight. So, where external recruitment is the right answer, the appointment should be approached as a business investment: with a clear case, a realistic understanding of the risk and defined measures of success.

Why a senior finance hire is a business investment

A senior finance appointment can change how a business sees risk, makes decisions and delivers its development plans. Yet many businesses still treat it as just another vacancy to fill. A business-critical finance appointment deserves the same due diligence as any capital investment.

That means building the case before the role goes to market. Be clear about the business problem, the results the appointment must deliver, and the conditions required for success. Without that clarity, the business can make an expensive appointment without resolving the issue that prompted it.

A strong candidate cannot compensate for an unclear investment case. Define what the business needs the appointment to achieve before deciding who to recruit.

Build the investment case

As we argued in Closing the capability gap: How to recruit for what's coming next, the first question isn’t: “Who do we need to replace?”, but: “What does the business need finance to do next?”

Better cash visibility, sharper commercial analysis, investor-grade reporting and leadership through change represent different investment cases. Each requires a different role, profile and definition of success. Be specific:

• What should be more reliable or better understood after six or twelve months?
• Which decisions should finance support more effectively?
• What should the team be able to do that it cannot do today?
• What commercial value or risk reduction should the appointment create?

Set a realistic scope

A senior appointment cannot compensate for an unclear operating model. If the real problem is insufficient capacity, poor information, unclear decision rights or an under-resourced team, address that before assuming another senior hire is the answer.

Separate what the person must bring on day one from what can be developed over time. Be equally clear about the resources, authority and support available. Combining every desirable quality in one profile creates an unrealistic brief and makes objective assessment more difficult.

Do not recruit one senior person to compensate for several unresolved structural problems.

Understand the exposure

Scarcity can add a premium. Robert Half found that 67% of UK finance and accounting hiring managers are willing to pay higher salaries when qualified talent for a role is scarce.

The full investment includes salary, benefits, search and selection, leadership time and onboarding. The exposure also includes the cost of delay, a prolonged vacancy or an appointment that fails to deliver.

A poor finance appointment spreads. The CFO or CEO keeps absorbing work, reporting improvements stall, decisions rest on weak analysis and stakeholders lose confidence. Rather than rely on a single multiplier (see More applicants, harder decisions), map what delay or a poor appointment would mean in your business: what won’t happen, which decisions will be weaker and who will carry the load.

 To understand more about your potential risk exposure, download the:

Finance capability risk map

Map the market

Once the case is clear, a well-run process follows four steps:

1. Build the case. Turn the business plan into a realistic brief that separates what is essential on day one from what can be developed.
2. Price the market. Map the availability and likely cost of the capability you need. Scarce skills can attract a premium, so check that the salary and opportunity will attract the calibre of talent required.
3. Search beyond the obvious. The strongest candidates are often not actively looking (see More applicants, harder decisions). Head hunting the passive market involves targeted research, deep market insight and a credible conversation about why the role is worth considering.
4. Test the investment. Agreed criteria, structured interviews, work-based scenarios and timely feedback help you tell confident presentation apart from the judgement, influence and learning agility the role needs.

Selection due diligence: test the evidence

For an appointment with this level of influence, a polished CV and confident interview are not sufficient evidence. The process should test candidates against the work they will actually be expected to perform.

A realistic business discussion or real-world business scenario shows how a candidate frames a problem, which assumptions they test and how they communicate their reasoning.

References should test the evidence behind the appointment, including how the person has previously led, handled pressure and developed others.

Assessment and profiling can also add useful insight, into leadership style and likely behaviour. To be clear, profiling should support judgement rather than replace it. Its value lies in adding another source of evidence and informing onboarding and development, not determining suitability in isolation.

Due diligence runs both ways. Strong candidates will assess the opportunity as carefully as you assess them. Give them an honest account of the business, the reason for the hire, the team they’ll inherit, the authority they’ll have and the challenges they’re being asked to solve.

Overselling the role may win an acceptance, but it weakens the conditions for a successful start.

Define the expected return

A business case for a senior hire can’t convert every contribution into a precise financial return. It should, however, set out the results that would justify the investment.

For example, one of our private equity-backed clients needed a CFO to support an ambitious buy-and-build and transformation strategy. The business had a clear view of the outcomes the appointment needed to deliver. These shaped both the search brief and the assessment process:

• Lead finance across the company’s largest international region
• Support and execute a high-velocity acquisition and integration programme
• Strengthen controls, governance, cash flow and working capital discipline
• Deliver enhanced board-level reporting and investor readiness
• Drive operational efficiency, margin expansion and synergy realisation
• Support longer-term value creation and exit preparation

The desired outcomes also set clear benchmarks against which progress could be assessed. It has taken around two-and-a-half years, but the appointed CFO has delivered on every one, including c.15% year-on-year revenue growth and a turnaround from a loss-making position to operating break-even.

Agree the priorities with the successful candidate and the stakeholders they will work with. Early milestones might cover stakeholder relationships, team assessment and a clear delivery plan. Longer-term measures might include stronger reporting, improved cash control, successful integration or more effective commercial decision-making.

A new leader needs time to understand the business, but that should not prevent the organisation from agreeing what progress should look like after 90 days, six months, twelve months and beyond.

Questions to ask before you invest

• What business outcome must this appointment improve?
• Is the current gap caused by capability, capacity, structure or decision-making?
• Which requirements are essential from day one, and which can be developed?
• What would delay or an unsuccessful appointment cost the business?
• How will we test judgement, leadership and the ability to complement the existing team?
• What authority, resources and support will the successful person need?

In brief

A senior finance appointment is a business investment. It commits money, leadership time and organisational trust in the expectation of stronger performance.

The return depends on more than selecting a capable candidate. It starts with defining the need accurately, testing the evidence carefully and giving the successful person the authority, resources and support to deliver.

Treating an appointment like an investment does not reduce a person to a line in a business case. It recognises that senior hiring decisions have consequences across the organisation and deserve corresponding clarity and due diligence.

The appointment is not the end of the investment decision. In the next article, we will look at how to help a senior finance hire land well and turn a strong appointment into lasting performance.

To receive articles like this direct to your Inbox

 Subscribe to our mailing list

• Transformation
• Strategic HR
• Business growth
• Finance Recruitment